Indianapolis Colts Fan Guide: When Did the Colts Win the Super Bowl?

This Indianapolis Colts fan guide contains information on Colts history and players, the best places to watch Colts games, Colts community events, and more.

Whether you’re a lifelong die-hard or have recently picked a new team, being a fan of the Indianapolis Colts means you’re part of a passionate community with a rich and storied past. However, understanding the history of the franchise takes more than just sitting down on Sundays in your blue and white apparel.

This ultimate guide for Colts fans will walk you through the team’s storied past and provide a close look at everything a good Colts fan needs to know. We’ll also look at how to have the best game day experience possible, whether that’s tailgating at Lucas Oil Stadium or watching with fellow fans from back home.

Colts History and Players To Know

The Colts were originally established in 1953 in Baltimore. After more than 30 seasons, a dispute related to the team’s stadium caused owner Jim Irsay and the rest of the organization to relocate across the country to the Hoosier State, who welcomed them in with open arms.

Since planting their roots in Indianapolis, the Colts have gone on to become one of the NFL’s most prestigious franchises. Several Colts have made a deep impact on the game, including 21 members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Some of the key players in the Colts’ history include:

Johnny Unitas, quarterback. Although Unitas never played for the Indianapolis Colts, he is a legendary figure from the Baltimore era. He is often remembered as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, having won Super Bowl V.
Peyton Manning, quarterback. Drafted in 1998, Manning is arguably the most significant player in the history of the Indianapolis Colts. He led the team to numerous playoff appearances, including a Super Bowl XLI victory in 2006.
Marvin Harrison, wide receiver. As one of Manning’s favorite targets, Harrison set numerous franchise records and helped capture a Super Bowl ring.
Reggie Wayne, wide receiver. Another key wide receiver during Manning’s tenure, Wayne is a Colts legend who ranks among the NFL’s all-time receiving leaders to this day.
Dwight Freeney, defensive end. Known for his fearsome pass-rushing abilities, Freeney was a cornerstone of the Colts’ defense during the 2000s.
Andrew Luck, quarterback. After Manning was injured and the Colts got the top pick in the 2012 NFL Draft, Luck led the team to the playoffs before his unexpected retirement in 2019.

Best Seasons in Colts History

Several seasons are defining moments in the Colts’ history, each marking a significant milestone in the team’s journey. Here are some of the highlights.

1984: When Did The Colts Leave Baltimore?

The Colts’ story in Indianapolis began in 1984. The move from Baltimore to Indianapolis was met with mixed emotions at first, but it ultimately established the Colts as Indiana’s team. The first few seasons in Indy were challenging, but the groundwork was laid for future success.

1995: Making the AFC Championship

In 1995, the Colts had one of their most memorable early seasons, making it to the AFC Championship game. Led by quarterback Jim Harbaugh, who went on to become a legendary coach, the Colts narrowly lost to the Pittsburgh Steelers in a gritty, heart-wrenching finish. Make no mistake, though, this season put the Colts on the map as a competitive team in the NFL.

1999: The Dawn of the Manning Era

The arrival of Peyton Manning in 1998 quickly transformed the Colts into perennial contenders. By 1999, Manning had already made a significant impact, leading the team to a 13 and 3 record and an AFC East title. Although they fell short in the playoffs, it was clear that the Colts were a force to be reckoned with.

2006: Super Bowl Champions

The pinnacle of Indianapolis Colts history came at the end of the 2006 season when they won Super Bowl XLI. With Manning as quarterback and Tony Dungy as head coach, the Colts defeated the Chicago Bears 29 to 17 in a rain-soaked thriller in Miami. This victory solidified the Colts’ status as one of the elite teams of the 2000s and brought Indianapolis its first Lombardi Trophy.

2012: Misfortune Turns to Good Luck

After Manning suffered a season-ending injury, the Colts had a disastrous year that ended with Manning leaving for the Denver Broncos and Indianapolis getting the top pick in the 2012 NFL Draft. With the franchise at a crossroads, the team quickly rebounded by drafting quarterback Andrew Luck, who led the Colts to the playoffs in his rookie season and sparked hope for a new era of success.

2019: Current Colts Generation Begins

During the 2019 preseason, Luck shocked the sports world by announcing his sudden retirement after years of injury troubles. With him gone, the team had to regroup quickly. With players like linebacker Darius Leonard and running back Jonathan Taylor emerging as key contributors, the Colts built a solid foundation for future success that can still be felt today.

Colts Merchandise: Which Colts Jersey Should I Buy?

Choosing the right Colts jersey for you depends on what you’re looking for. Are you interested in picking someone on the current team so you can celebrate when they score? Or would you prefer a timeless legend whose jersey you can wear forever? Here are a few suggestions:

Peyton Manning Colts jersey. An “18” jersey will always be a hit in Indianapolis, as it represents the golden age of Colts football.
Reggie Wayne. Another classic pick, wearing Wayne’s jersey, shows you have an appreciation for the past.
Jonathan Taylor. As the most exciting player currently on the Colts’ roster, Taylor’s jersey is one of the most frequently seen.
Quenton Nelson. An offensive lineman may not seem like the first player to choose, but Nelson is a fan favorite who is the heart and soul of the team.
Customized. What better way to get yourself invested in football season than by ordering a customized jersey with your name and number?

A group of friends tailgate outside of the stadium with drinks and food.

Best Places To Watch Colts Games

Watching the Colts play on Sunday, Monday, or Thursday is the most important part of being a good fan. We definitely recommend making the trip to Lucas Oil Stadium to catch a game in person, especially if you’ve never been, but here are some other places in Indianapolis to watch the Colts:

Kilroy’s Bar & Grill. Located near Lucas Oil Stadium, Kilroy’s is a favorite among Colts fans for its lively atmosphere and proximity to the game-day action.
The Slippery Noodle Inn. As Indiana’s oldest bar, The Slippery Noodle Inn is a historic spot to catch the game while enjoying live music and great food.
Ale Emporium. This bar has tons of beers on tap and tons of TVs, so you can watch all the action. Ale Emporium is also known for its world-famous Hermanaki Wings!
Taylor’s Pub. With a slightly more reserved vibe than the loud and crowded downtown bars, Taylor’s offers refreshing drinks and delicious ranch-seasoned pretzels.
Broad Ripple Tavern. Right on the Broad Ripple strip, Broad Ripple Tavern is an iconic spot for Indianapolis residents during Colts games and the rest of the weekend.

Tips for Joining Colts Fan Clubs

Joining a Colts fan club can enhance your game-day experience and connect you with other passionate fans. The Blue Crew is one of the most well-known Colts fan clubs. They organize tailgates, road trips, and events throughout the year, providing a fantastic way to immerse yourself in the Colts community. The official Colts Fan Club also offers exclusive perks, including discounts on merchandise, special event invitations, and even opportunities to meet players.

Colts Community Events

The Colts are more than just a football team—they’re a vital part of the Indianapolis community. The team hosts various events throughout the year that allow fans to get involved and give back.

Colts training camp. Held annually at Grand Park in Westfield, the Colts training camp is an opportunity for fans to see the team up close as they prepare for the season. It’s a family-friendly event with activities, autograph sessions, and more.
Colts 5K. The Colts 5K is a popular event that takes place at Lucas Oil Stadium. Fans can run or walk the 5K course, with the race finishing on the 50-yard line. It’s a great way to stay active and support the team.
Community Tuesdays. Every Tuesday during the season, Colts players and staff participate in various community service events across Indianapolis. This initiative strengthens the bond between the team and the community, making the Colts more than just a football team but a force for good in the city.

Tailgating Tips for Colts Games

Tailgating is a beloved tradition for Colts fans, and getting it right can make your game-day experience even more enjoyable. To make sure you have a good spot and plenty of time to set up, arrive at least three to four hours before kickoff, maybe more if it’s a night game. Bring plenty of food and drinks, a portable grill if you’re cooking, chairs, and a tent or canopy for shade. A Bluetooth speaker is also great for streaming sports radio or playing music to get everyone in the spirit. Don’t forget your Colts gear, including jerseys, hats, and flags, to show your team pride!

Store Your Colts Game Day Gear With Storage of America

As a dedicated Colts fan, you likely have a lot of gear—from your tailgating grill and cornhole boards to your flags and other decorations. While you still may be locked in on the draft and free agency during the offseason, storing Colts memorabilia can take up a lot of space while not in use, so finding effective football fan storage solutions is important.

Thankfully, Storage of America is here to help! We offer several options for Colts fan gear storage with locations across the state that are perfect for protecting Colts collectibles until next season rolls around. We have climate controlled storage units available in many sizes that are equipped with strong safety features to give you peace of mind.

Find your closest Storage of America facility in Indiana to get started today!